Paid media is entering its “plot twist” era. Privacy rules keep tightening, acquisition costs climb like they’re trying to outpace inflation, and AI evolves so quickly that most internal playbooks feel like yesterday’s news. As 2026 approaches, CMOs and marketing leaders are juggling a familiar challenge with a new twist: stretch the budget, sharpen measurement, and still deliver profitable growth.

Analysts from WARC, eMarketer, Forbes, and Business Insider are aligned. The next 18 months will reward brands that embrace experimentation, causality-driven measurement, and automation while keeping a firm grip on financial discipline. Those still relying on vanity metrics and decade-old attribution models can likely find the ground moving under them.

Below are six predictions that reveal how paid media is shifting and the actions leaders should prioritise.

Prediction 1: Incrementality Becomes the New North Star Metric

As attribution noise intensifies, incrementality moves from a “testing tactic” to a core budgeting framework. eMarketer reports that many marketers still rely on cookies for measurement, even as those signals erode, creating widening gaps between platform-reported performance and reality. This fragility in traditional measurement is colliding with rising executive scrutiny. Yahoo Finance highlights that CMOs are under pressure to demonstrate clearer financial outcomes, with brand and performance investment now expected to show tangible business impact.

At the same time, NIQ’s 2026 Outlook notes that CMOs face a “reputation and results reckoning,” driven by heightened expectations around accountability, profitability, and data-driven decisioning. As platforms automate delivery and remove manual levers, the only defensible way to allocate spend is by understanding causal impact: what would have happened without the ad.

Crealytics’ Incrementality Benchmark Report reinforces this shift. Traditional ROAS often inflates performance because it captures purchases that were already in motion. Incrementality isolates the lift that matters: the behavioural change directly caused by the ad exposure.

What marketing leaders should do

• Anchor quarterly planning to incremental revenue, not reported conversions or platform ROAS.

• Establish always-on incrementality testing across Search, Social, and Display.

• Rebuild dashboards around cost per incremental conversion, iROAS, and new-customer incrementality.

• Upskill teams on causal design principles to avoid misinterpreting automated platform signals.

Prediction 2: AI-Native Campaigns Replace Manual Optimisation

Google, Meta, and Microsoft are accelerating AI-led buying. By 2026 more than 80% of digital ad spend will run through automated formats such as PMax, Advantage+, and AI-driven bidding. These systems will increasingly operate as closed ecosystems where manual tweaks deliver diminishing returns and platform opacity becomes the default. While AI reduces operational burden, it introduces a more complex strategic challenge. Leaders must govern the inputs, data quality, audience signals, creative supply, and profitability constraints, rather than the outputs. The risk is that without disciplined oversight, AI can optimise toward volume instead of value, favour high-intent audiences that inflate apparent performance, or overspend into marginal returns. Teams also lose line-of-sight into why decisions are being made, making diagnosis harder when performance shifts.

The organisations that win will treat AI not as autopilot, but as a system requiring rigorous guardrails, creative pipelines built for scale, and measurement frameworks that validate true incremental impact.

Relevant case study: How Crealytics’ Award-Recognized AI Innovation Is Transforming Paid Media

What marketing leaders should do

• Shift team capabilities from button-pushing to scenario planning, modelling, and governance.

• Define strict guardrails for audience, geographic reach, and profitability constraints.

• Build a creative engine that can supply modular assets at scale, since AI thrives on volume and variation.

• Audit platform machine-learning biases through controlled tests.

Prediction 3: Creative Quality Becomes the Primary Performance Lever

As automation equalises delivery, creative becomes the key differentiator. Research from Nielsen and System1 shows that creative quality is now the single biggest driver of ROI, far more than media targeting or budget allocation.

In 2026, teams that treat creative as a strategic growth driver rather than a production task will pull ahead. Growth-oriented brands are already consolidating brand, performance, and social creative into unified pipelines to feed algorithmic systems.

What marketing leaders should do

• Invest in a creative testing roadmap that challenges assumptions quarterly.

• Scale production without diluting brand; AI generation and modular templates can support speed.

• Introduce creative-level incrementality tests to distinguish correlation from true causal lift.

• Connect creative performance to financial outcomes, not engagement metrics.

Prediction 4: Privacy Disruption Accelerates and Redefines Targeting

Privacy regulation is tightening faster than ad tech can adapt. Gartner expects that there will be increased regulatory scrutiny and enforcement related to AI, youth privacy, and data brokers, particularly in the US at the state level through 2026. Apple and Google continue to limit cross-site identifiers, reducing signal availability and pushing “unknown sources” to the top of analytics dashboards.

With the erosion of retargeting and behavioural precision, contextual intelligence, CRM-based frameworks, and clean rooms become the foundation for targeting.

What marketing leaders should do

• Prioritise first-party data enrichment and consent strategies.

• Adopt privacy-safe measurement techniques such as geo-experiments, matched-market holdouts, and conversion lift tests.

• Build partnerships with publishers for contextual and signal-rich placements.

• Stress-test your tech stack for data loss scenarios.

Prediction 5: Full-Funnel Orchestration Replaces Last-Click Thinking

There will be a steady migration of budgets toward upper- and mid-funnel channels, with video ad spend projected to exceed $120B globally in 2026. Leaders are recognising that performance deteriorates without sustained reach and brand familiarity.

Sophisticated marketers are integrating MMM, incrementality, and platform-based lift tests to understand cross-channel synergies. Last-click is losing relevance as a planning model.

What marketing leaders should do

• Set clear investment ratios across awareness, consideration, and conversion tiers.

• Use MMM and incrementality in tandem to triangulate causal effects across the funnel.

• Measure financial contribution, not isolated channel return.

• Build durable signals with content that grows familiarity, not just performance assets.

Prediction 6: Profitability Becomes the Universal KPI

As acquisition costs rise and consumer demand softens in several markets, CFO scrutiny intensifies. Statista reports that CPCs across key retail categories have climbed by double digits year over year, while consumer spending growth in the US and Europe is slowing, creating tighter margins and greater pressure on operational efficiency. With this backdrop, brands can no longer pursue growth at any cost; profitability alignment becomes the governing principle.

CFOs are demanding clearer accountability because media now represents one of the largest discretionary budget lines, and its financial impact is often overstated by platform-reported metrics. Marketing teams must connect media investment to contribution margin, inventory position, and customer lifetime value. Incremental profit per ad dollar becomes the executive-level KPI, replacing ROAS as the language of budget justification and strategic planning.

What marketing leaders should do

• Replace channel-level ROAS targets with margin-aligned models.

• Introduce profitability guardrails to all AI-driven campaigns.

• Factor LTV and retention propensity into bidding and forecasting.

• Partner with Finance to create unified dashboards that reflect true business impact.

Final Thoughts: 2026 Rewards the Measurement-Mature, Not the Spend-Heavy

Paid media in 2026 will continue to challenge familiar playbooks. Advantage will go to organisations that operationalise incrementality, govern AI systems with discipline, elevate creative, and anchor decisions in profitability. The next wave of performance growth will come not from spending more, but from understanding what actually moves the needle.

Leaders who adopt a causal, financially-driven, experimentation-led mindset will enter 2026 with confidence, while the rest might continue optimising symptoms rather than sources of performance.

---

Need help refresh your paid media accounts in 2026? Reach out to us!

Relevant Insights:

· Article: Will LLMs Replace Search Engines? How Brands Can Stay Visible in the AI Age

· Article: Q&A: Lessons from Managing and Auditing Global Paid Media Budgets across Retailers and DTC Brands

· Video: Triangulation: How to Master Your Marketing Measurement and Maximize ROI

About Crealytics

Crealytics is an award-winning full-funnel digital marketing agency fueling the profitable growth of over 100 well-known B2C and B2B businesses, including ASOS, The Hut Group, Staples and Urban Outfitters. A global company with an inclusive team of 100+ international employees, we operate from our hubs in Berlin, New York, Chicago, London, and Mumbai.