Blog

The $1 Trillion Holiday Season: Where Should US Retailers Place Their Next Advertising Dollar?

Akash Bhajanka
•
November 12, 2026
Share
Jump to Title

US holiday retail sales are forecast to reach $1.013 trillion in 2026, the first time the season has crossed that threshold. The figure covers November and December and comes from the National Retail Federation, which puts year-over-year growth at 4.2%. Online sales are carrying a disproportionate share of that growth: Forrester projects holiday ecommerce to rise 11.6% year over year, accounting for nearly 60% of all incremental holiday retail growth despite representing just over a quarter of total sales.

The scale of the season creates a specific kind of pressure on media allocation decisions. With budgets concentrated into a narrow window and every channel reporting strong in-season performance, the question of where the next advertising dollar goes is harder to answer than it looks. Platform ROAS climbs across the board during Cyber Week, upper-funnel channels appear to underperform against lower-funnel ones in real-time dashboards, and the temptation to concentrate spend where the numbers look best is at its strongest. Getting that allocation right before the season starts is the work that determines whether the trillion-dollar opportunity converts into durable growth or just a flattering Q4 report.

Why AI-Assisted Discovery Is Reshaping How Holiday Shoppers Find and Evaluate Products

The most consequential structural shift in holiday shopping behavior this season is the role of AI in the discovery and evaluation process. Adobe's 2026 holiday forecast projects AI-referred traffic to US retail sites up 130% year over year, with Thanksgiving seeing a 159% spike and Black Friday up 95%. For media planning purposes, the more instructive finding is behavioral: shoppers using AI tools in their purchase journey interact with or notice roughly 12.1 touchpoints on average, compared to 4.2 for those who do not, according to Google-commissioned research.

A shopper touching nearly three times as many signals before converting is a shopper whose path to purchase is more distributed across channels and moments than the last-click attribution model captures. That has two practical implications for media allocation. First, upper-funnel channels that influence earlier touchpoints in that journey are carrying more conversion weight than platform-reported ROAS assigns them. Second, the brands appearing consistently across the AI discovery layer, search, YouTube, and Shopping, are building consideration share that lower-funnel campaigns later convert. The advertisers concentrating spend entirely at the bottom of the funnel are capturing demand their competitors' upper-funnel investment helped create.

How Search Investment and Retail Media Work Together at Peak, and Why Separating Them Is Costly

US retail media ad spending is projected to approach $70 billion in 2026, making it the dominant and fastest-growing segment of the digital ad market. For most large US retailers, the peak season question is not whether to invest in retail media but how to coordinate it with paid search and Shopping so the two channels reinforce each other's performance rather than competing for the same budget and audience.

The coordination failure that most commonly surfaces at peak is a structural one: retail media campaigns and Google Search campaigns are managed by separate teams against separate ROAS targets, with no shared signal layer connecting them. A shopper who engaged with a Sponsored Products placement on a retail network and then searched on Google for the same brand is treated as two separate audience segments by two separate campaign architectures. The first-party data generated by the retail media interaction — purchase intent, category affinity, basket composition is available to inform the Google campaign's bidding and targeting, but only if the data infrastructure connects them.

Building that connection before Black Friday is the highest-leverage technical investment most retailers can make in their peak season setup. An Ekimetrics meta-analysis of 64 marketing-mix models found that brands weighted toward Google Search had a median Q4 total media ROI 74% higher than brands weighted toward paid social. The implication is that the brands getting the most from peak season have Search at the core of their media architecture, with retail media signal feeding into it.

Relevant Article: From Awareness to Conversion: The Formula Behind Viral, High-Performing Holiday Campaigns

The Case for Holding Upper-Funnel Investment Steady When In-Window ROAS Tells You to Cut It

The pattern that consistently damages peak season media efficiency is the mid-flight budget reallocation triggered by real-time ROAS data. Upper-funnel channels, CTV, YouTube prospecting, and awareness-oriented paid social, produce their conversion lift over days and weeks after the impression, while lower-funnel channels capture it in the same session. US CTV ad spending is projected to exceed $37 billion in 2026, yet CTV consistently registers weak in-window ROAS during Cyber Week because the channel's influence materializes well after the last-click attribution window closes. A real-time dashboard review in late November will flag CTV and upper-funnel video as underperforming at precisely the moment they are delivering the most incremental consideration.

The retailers who avoid this trap are the ones who entered the season with a channel-level understanding of where attributed ROAS and incremental ROAS diverge. That understanding comes from incrementality testing run outside the peak window, in Q2 or Q3, when holding out a control group does not carry the same revenue cost. The output is a channel-level baseline that tells the planning team which channels to protect from in-flight cuts even when the dashboard makes the case for cutting them.

Social commerce is a parallel example. Adobe's data shows social-referred revenue growing 17% year over year this holiday season, outpacing paid search growth of 4% in revenue share terms. The growth is real, but social's measurement environment makes last-click attribution particularly unreliable: social impressions frequently precede a search that closes the conversion, and that search gets the credit. Holding social investment steady during peak, based on incrementality data established before it, is a more defensible position than reacting to daily platform ROAS during Cyber Week.

Relevant Case Study: Unlocking Incremental Growth for Paid Social: How Retailer X Proved the Value of Meta Ads Prospecting

What Cyber Monday's $15 Billion Tells Retailers About Concentration Risk in Their Media Plans

Adobe projects Cyber Monday 2026 as the largest online shopping day on record at $15.1 billion, with Cyber Week as a whole accounting for $47.5 billion, or roughly 17% of the entire holiday season's online sales compressed into five days. The concentration of consumer demand into that window creates a specific media allocation problem: CPCs and CPMs spike as every advertiser competes for the same high-intent audience simultaneously, the incremental value of an additional dollar of spend during Cyber Week is lower than the same dollar spent in the weeks before it, and the brands that built consideration during October and early November convert at a higher rate when the demand peak arrives.

Adobe's pre-season data supports this. October pre-season spend is projected at $95.8 billion, up 8% year over year, outpacing the in-season growth rate on some key days. The implication for media planning is that the full holiday season allocation should be sequenced, not concentrated: upper-funnel and consideration investment in October, conversion investment in Cyber Week, and a retention-oriented layer in December to capture the post-peak repurchase cycle from customers acquired at the front of the season.

Building a Peak Season Media Plan That Reflects the Full Funnel, Not Just the Last Click

The trillion-dollar holiday season is not evenly distributed across channels, timing, or customer journey stages, and a media plan built on last-click attribution treats it as if it were. The retailers who allocate well this season are the ones who enter November with a channel-level incrementality baseline, a Search and retail media architecture that shares signal, and an upper-funnel investment thesis that does not depend on in-window ROAS for its justification.

The practical starting point is sequencing the season around when each channel delivers its value: build consideration in October when CPCs are lower and AI-assisted discovery is active, concentrate conversion spend in Cyber Week against audiences already primed by earlier touchpoints, and use December to retain the new customers the front of the season acquired. Each stage of that sequence has a different measurement requirement, and trying to evaluate all of it through the same real-time ROAS lens is what produces the mid-flight reallocation decisions that flatten the season's true return.

Key Takeaways

What the data suggests

· US holiday retail sales are forecast to reach $1.013 trillion in 2026, with ecommerce accounting for 11.6% growth year over year and nearly 60% of all incremental holiday retail gains, according to Forrester.

· Adobe projects AI-referred traffic to retail sites up 130% this holiday season, with shoppers using AI tools averaging 12.1 purchase touchpoints versus 4.2 for those who do not, indicating a more distributed path to conversion that last-click attribution systematically undercounts.

· Cyber Monday is projected at $15.1 billion and Cyber Week at $47.5 billion, representing 17% of the season's online sales in five days. CPC and CPM inflation during that window makes pre-season investment in October, when demand is building and media costs are lower, a more efficient use of upper-funnel budget.

The Crealytics view

· The highest-leverage investment most US retailers can make before Black Friday is connecting retail media first-party signal to their Google Search and Shopping campaign architecture. The two channels should share audience data, not compete for budget against separate ROAS targets.

· Upper-funnel channels, CTV, YouTube, and awareness-oriented social, will show weak in-window ROAS during Cyber Week and deliver most of their incremental value in the conversion tail that follows. Protecting that investment from mid-flight cuts requires a channel-level incrementality baseline established before the season, not a real-time dashboard justification during it.

· Peak season media plans that concentrate spend in Cyber Week are competing at the highest CPCs of the year against audiences that brands weighted toward October consideration investment have already primed. Sequencing the season is not a planning preference; it is an efficiency decision.

---

Unsure whether your holiday budget is actually driving incremental growth? Reach out to us.

Relevant Insights

· Article: Peak Season Checklist: How to Drive Full-Funnel Growth During the Holidays

· Case Study: Holiday Season Success: How We Delivered 65% Higher Revenue with 24% Less Budget for a Leading Fashion Brand

· Article: 2026 U.S. Holiday Shopping Trends: What Brands Need to Know

About Crealytics

Crealytics is an award-winning full-funnel digital marketing agency fueling the profitable growth of over 100 well-known B2C and B2B businesses, including ASOS, The Hut Group, Staples and Urban Outfitters. A global company with an inclusive team of 100+ international employees, we operate from our hubs in Berlin, New York, Chicago, London, and Mumbai.

Subscribe to the Crealytics newsletter

Stay updated with cutting-edge insights into the latest digital marketing developments and trends.

You’re subscribed to our newsletter. Stay tuned for updates and exclusive content!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.