It’s never been easier to launch a campaign. Platforms like Google Performance Max and Meta Advantage+ handle targeting, bidding, creativerotation, and budget allocation. Plug in some assets, hit publish campaigns, and you’re live across dozens of placements.

Together, these tools now power most paid media buys. According to eMarketer, 57% of US digital ad buyers had used or planned to use AI-powered performance products like Performance Max as of August 2024.

But as automation takes over execution, strategy fades into the background. Campaigns move faster, but not always smarter. Marketers start optimizing for what’s easy, not what’s effective.

The question isn’t whether automation is bad. It’s what happens when we treat it as the strategy, not just a tool.

What Can Google Performance Max and Meta Advantage+ Actually Do, and Where Do They Fall Short?

Google Performance Max (PMax) runs ads across Search, YouTube, Display, Gmail, and Maps, automating bidding, targeting, creative rotation, and budgets.

Meta’s Advantage+ Shopping campaigns, similarly, drive scale with minimal setup. While Meta reports better results than standard campaigns, both tools are heavily automated.

The drawback?

· Opaque reporting: Despite recent updates, true channel and asset performance visibility remain limited. Google recently added channel-level breakdowns, but features like asset-attribution and spend allocation across channels are still improving. Advertisers and analysts, included in a Wall Street Journal piece, note the platform leaves little visibility into which audiences or creative elements drive performance.

· Context lost: Without transparency, marketers don’t know which placement or creative is doing the heavy lifting or which may just be wasting budget.

Learn from our Masterclass in Performance Max and how we can blend in with its capabilities to automate.

What Do Marketers Lose When They Rely Too Heavily on Automation in Performance Marketing?

Automation saves time. But when it replaces actual marketing judgment, it quietly erodes the core elements that make campaigns effective, not just efficient.

Creative Quality Gets Watered Down

The same five assets recycled across every placement. Creative that checks the box but never gets remembered. According to Nielsen, creativity drives 56% of a campaign’s sales ROI, and Google reports that 70% of a campaign’s success is determined by the creative. So when creative becomes an afterthought, so does performance.

Audience Control Goes Out the Window

PMax often defaults to broad match, dynamic audiences, and automatic expansion all aimed at maximizing volume. But not all clicks are created equal. Without thoughtful audience exclusions, first-party layering, or control over brand vs non-brand traffic, performance marketers risk paying for impressions that don’t convert, or worse, that cannibalize organic sales.

Budget is Wasted

One of the biggest risks with automation is misallocated spend. Platforms often funnel budget toward:

· low-value placements (where clicks are cheap but conversions are rare), or

· overly broad audiences that generate impressions without meaningful returns.

Without manual oversight, marketers end up burning budget on activity that looks good on a dashboard but doesn’t move the needle. See how our audit helped a major luxury retailer increase 2-year incremental profit by 42% to $28.2M through budget allocation.

Measurement Becomes Misleading

Automated platforms often surface top-line ROAS and conversion metrics, but these numbers can be misleading. Without incrementality testing, media mix modeling, or even basic A/B holds, marketers can’t tell whether conversions are genuinely influenced by ads or would’ve happened anyway.

Automation Doesn’t Understand Business Context

Automation sees signals. It doesn’t see your stock levels, promo calendar, or margin targets. It won’t slow down spend when your inventory is low or ramp up to hit end-of-quarter goals. Without human oversight, campaigns continue to “optimize” even when conditions demand a shift.

This is especially risky during peak retail periods. Campaigns that overspend early or fail to pivot mid-flight often leave money, and learning, on the table.

In short, automation can handle the how, but it doesn’t know why. And when you stop asking “why,” you start losing the plot.

When Does Automation Work and When Does It Need a Human Strategy?

Automation is built for speed and volume. It streamlines tasks like bid optimization, creative rotation, and real-time placement decisions. Yet it struggles with intentionality.

Platforms lack:

· Strategic clarity on when and where to show brand vs. performance messages

· Creative differentiation, since everyone uses the same tools and asset pools

· Channel nuance, with minimal transparency on cross-channel impact

If growth slows or CPA spikes, the problem isn’t automation. It’s the lack of a human in the loop.

How to Bring Strategy Back into Automated Media Buying?

Let’s break down four ways marketers can bring the why back into campaign execution:

Start With Strategy, Not Setup

Before you launch a PMax or Advantage+ campaign, you still need to define:

· What are you trying to achieve? (Awareness? Acquisition? Retention?)

· Who matters most right now? (New customers? High-value repeat buyers?)

· What’s your key message or creative angle?

· How are you measuring success?

Curate inputs carefully

Automated tools run on the creative you feed them. If you’re lazy with inputs, generic headlines, stock images, recycled videos, expect mediocre results.

Creative is the most important factor when it comes to performance. Nielsen reports that 56% of campaign performance can be explained through creativity. And yet, many marketers rely on a few recycled creatives or low-effort templates hoping the algorithm will do the rest.

This is where marketers need to step in. Understand what resonates with your audience. Test formats. Refresh assets based on insights. AI might pick the winning ad, but only humans can craft one that truly connects.

Prioritize First-Party Data

Don’t just rely on what platforms think your audience looks like. When you use your own CRM, purchase history, or engagement data:

· Targeting improves

· Personalization becomes sharper

· And you gain visibility that platform automation can’t offer

First-party data is your biggest edge in an opaque ecosystem.

Analyze Performance with a Human Lens

Automation provides dashboards, but not insight. If your campaign starts tanking are you over-indexing on branded search? Is one region dragging down ROAS? Is your audience fatigued by the same message?

PMax and Advantage+ often hide these nuances. This makes attribution modeling, new customer acquisition tracking, and incrementality analysis even more essential, and all of these require human interpretation.

Set Smarter Conversion Values

Don’t let the platform decide what “success” looks like. Instead of chasing click-through rates or raw conversions, optimize for metrics that matter:

· Customer lifetime value (CLV)

· High-margin products

· Subscription sign-ups over one-off purchases

The closer your goals are to business outcomes, the more valuable your automation becomes. See how we helped this omni-retailer increase new customers by 59% and margin by 34% through CLV-based advertising.

Is Automation Replacing Strategy or Just Making Us Lazy?

AI-driven campaign types such as Performance Max and Advantage+ can scale what works but they can also scale what’s broken. If you hand over your budget, your creative, your audience strategy, and your KPIs without asking why or how, then you're not automating, you’re abdicating.

So yes, use the tools. Let them do the heavy lifting. But don’t forget who’s supposed to be driving. Strategy doesn’t come from an algorithm. It comes from you.

---

Want to build automated campaigns with strategic intention? Reach out to us!

About Crealytics

Crealytics is an award-winning full-funnel digital marketing agency fueling the profitable growth of over 100 well-known B2C and B2B businesses, including ASOS, The Hut Group, Staples and Urban Outfitters. A global company with an inclusive team of 100+ international employees, we operate from our hubs in Berlin, New York, Chicago, London, and Mumbai.